Welding Defects Guide: Types, Causes, How to Detect and Prevent.

Welding defects are an inevitable challenge in welding processes, and understanding them is essential for ensuring the quality and safety of welded structures. These imperfections can significantly impact the strength, appearance, and durability of welds. This comprehensive guide provides an in-depth analysis of welding defects, detailing types, causes, prevention methods, and modern detection techniques such as Xiris Weld Cameras. It equips you with the knowledge to optimize welding processes, minimize errors, and improve overall weld quality.

Cold-Wire-GMAW-Process-Steel-Flat-Bead-Side-View-Cropped-gif-1

 

Screen Shot 2024-11-14 at 2.35.22 PM

What Are Welding Defects?

Welding defects, or imperfections, are unwanted irregularities found in welds that can compromise the structural integrity and aesthetic quality of the welded piece. These defects, ranging from visible distortions to internal flaws, stem from various causes such as technique, material selection, and environmental conditions. Understanding each defect and its potential solutions can greatly improve the quality of welding projects, making this knowledge essential for any welder or industry professional.

Categories of Welding Defects

Welding defects are typically classified into distinct categories, each reflecting specific aspects of the welding process that directly impact joint integrity and quality. This article will focus on three primary categories: dimensional imperfections, discontinuities, and surface defects, which arise as a result of welding parameters, application techniques, and process control.

1. Dimensional imperfections

Dimensional imperfections

Dimensional imperfections refer to issues in the shape or size of the weld bead, which can impact the weld’s structural integrity and durability. These defects often result from incorrect welding techniques or improper filler metal application, leading to weak joints or excessive material on the weld. 

Common Defects Description
Under filled Occurs when the weld bead lacks sufficient filler metal, resulting in weak joints.
Undercut A groove at the weld toe that reduces the cross-sectional thickness of the base metal.
Overlap Excess weld metal flows beyond the edge without bonding with the base metal.
Excess reinforcement Too much filler metal on the weld bead, increasing the risk of cracking under stress.
Burn through Results from excessive heat, causing the weld to penetrate through the base material.
2. Discontinuities

Discontinuities

Discontinuities are imperfections that interrupt the uniformity of the weld, creating areas of weakness that may compromise the overall strength and reliability of the welded joint. These defects can result from poor welding practices or environmental factors during the welding process. 

Common Defects Description
Poor penetration Occurs when the weld does not penetrate deeply into the base material, leading to weak bonds.
Lack of fusion Failure of the weld metal to properly bond with the base metal, resulting in weak joints.
Cracks Fractures that occur within or on the surface of the weld, potentially spreading and weakening the weld.
3. Surface Defects

Surface Defects

Surface defects refer to imperfections that appear on the weld's surface, impacting both its appearance and, potentially, its structural integrity. These defects often arise from issues like contamination, rapid cooling, or inconsistent welding techniques. Surface defects can weaken the weld by creating stress concentration points or by allowing external elements, like moisture or corrosive agents, to penetrate, which may lead to further degradation.

Common Defects Description
Spatter Small metal droplets that adhere to the surface around the weld, affecting appearance and quality.
Porosity Gas bubbles trapped within the weld, creating weak spots and reducing strength.
4. Metallurgical Defects

Metallurgical Defects

Imperfections related to the material properties and structural composition of the weld. These issues often arise due to improper heat treatment, rapid cooling, or variations in the composition of the weld and base metals. Metallurgical defects can weaken the weld by creating areas with different hardness, brittleness, or strength, leading to potential failure under stress. They may also affect the weld's resistance to corrosion or impact, depending on the environment and the welding process. 

Common Defects Description
Segregation Uneven distribution of alloying elements within the weld, causing inconsistent mechanical properties.
Microcracks Small fissures within the weld metal that can lead to material failure under stress.

What are 10 the common Types of Weld Defects?

1. Underfill

Underfill occurs when there is insufficient weld metal in the joint, often due to low heat or inadequate filler material. This defect leads to a weld with a concave profile, where the joint lacks the necessary volume to bear structural loads. 

Technical implications

The reduced weld volume directly impacts the joint's load distribution, making it vulnerable in applications with dynamic or concentrated stress points. Underfill welds often require rework in industrial settings, where precision and safety are paramount.

Common causes
  • Low Filler Metal Input: Insufficient filler metal during welding.
  • Low Heat Input: Inadequate heat input creates a concave, undersized weld bead.
  • Inappropriate Travel Speed: Improper travel speed fails to allow adequate material deposition.
How to prevent
  • Increase filler metal deposition to create an adequately sized weld bead and avoid concave profiles.
  • Adjust heat input to enable full coverage across the joint; maintain steady travel speed for uniformity.
  • Apply multiple passes if needed to achieve the required thickness for load-bearing joints.

Underfill defect images

Underfill diagram
Underfill-1
Test caption
Underfill 2
Underfill 3
Underfill 4
Underfill 5

Video: Plasma - Robotic Assembly - Inconel (Turbine Fuel Injector) - Underfill Defect

This footage captures plasma arc welding (PAW) applied in a robotic setup for an Inconel turbine fuel injector. The process exhibits high thermal efficiency but presents an underfill defect. Such defects could impact fatigue resistance and necessitate parameter optimization for improved consistency.

Video: GMAW – Butt Weld – Carbon Steel – Underfill Defect

This footage captures gas metal arc welding (GMAW) applied for a butt weld joint with V-groove. Due to inadequate and increasing groove gap, the weld pool sinks and does not fill the groove sufficiently. As a result, an underfill defect occurs.

2. Undercut

Undercut is a defect seen as a groove along the weld toe where the base metal is eroded due to excess heat or high travel speed, leaving a depression that reduces the weld's effective cross-sectional area. This groove is often a product of disproportionate heat input, where the arc or torch melts the edge of the parent metal without fusing it back with additional filler. 

Technical implications

The reduction in cross-sectional area acts as a stress concentrator, creating a vulnerable point susceptible to fatigue failure. In load-bearing structures, undercuts can significantly compromise the weld’s ability to withstand cyclic loading, leading to premature cracking.

Common causes
  • High Current: Excessive current that erodes the base metal edges.
  • High Travel Speed: High travel speed limits fusion time, leaving exposed edges.
  • Incorrect Electrode Angle: Inappropriate electrode angle directs heat towards edges without bonding.
How to prevent
  • Lower the welding current to avoid excessive heat at the edges of the weld.
  • Reduce travel speed to allow more bonding time; maintain a 5-15° electrode angle for even heat distribution.
  • Use a weave technique to fill the edges effectively, especially on vertical welds.

Undercut defect images

Undercut

Video: GMAW – Fillet Weld – Carbon Steel – Undercut Defect

This footage shows the formation of an undercut defect in gas metal arc welding (GMAW) of a fillet weld. Due to inadequately high wire feed rate and travel speed, the excessive arc pressure in the spray transfer mode leads to the formation of an undercut defect.

Video: GMAW – Lap joint – Carbon Steel – Undercut Defect

This footage shows the formation of an undercut defect in gas metal arc welding (GMAW) of a lap joint. Too high wire feed rate and travel speed lead to the formation of an undercut defect on the edge of the top plate.

3. Lack of penetration

Insufficient penetration is particularly problematic in applications with high-stress demands, as it compromises the weld’s ability to distribute load evenly. In load-bearing structures, this flaw necessitates rework to meet structural requirements. 

Technical implications

The reduced weld volume directly impacts the joint's load distribution, making it vulnerable in applications with dynamic or concentrated stress points. Under-filled welds often require rework in industrial settings, where precision and safety are paramount.

Common causes
  • Low Current Settings: Corriente insuficiente que no alcanza la profundidad necesaria en la junta.
  • High Travel Speed: Velocidad alta que reduce la capacidad del arco para penetrar completamente.
  • Improper Joint Fit-Up: Alineación deficiente de la junta que limita el acceso del arco a toda la superficie de la junta.
How to prevent
  • Increase current to reach the required depth within the joint, ensuring robust penetration.
  • Lower travel speed for improved penetration; adjust electrode angle for full access.
  • Ensure a proper joint fit-up to allow full arc exposure across the entire joint surface.

Lack of penetration defect images

Poor-penetration

4. Lack of fusion

Lack of fusion describes the incomplete bonding between layers of weld metal, often due to inadequate penetration or improper torch angles. This defect is especially common in multi-pass welding, where inter-pass cleaning is insufficient. 

Technical implications

Lack of fusion weakens the weld interface, rendering it susceptible to delamination and cracking under stress. In critical applications, such as bridge construction or structural frameworks, this flaw necessitates strict inspection and rework protocols to ensure stability.

Common causes
  • Low Current Settings: Low current that limits the arc's penetration capability.
  • Poor Joint Preparation: Inadequate joint preparation that hinders the interaction of the materials.
  • Fast Travel Speed: Excessive speed that reduces the heat exposure time necessary for melting.
How to prevent
  • Raise current settings to achieve deeper penetration and complete bonding along the joint.
  • Prepare joint surfaces by cleaning thoroughly to remove contaminants that can obstruct fusion.
  • Reduce travel speed to give the weld pool enough time to melt and fuse properly.

Learn more about Lack of Fusion

Using Video and Audio to Help Detect Welding Defects

 

Lack of fusion images

Lack of fusion diagram
Lack of fusion - 1
Lack of fusion 2
Lack of fusion 3
Lack of fusion 4
Lack of fusion 5

Video: GMAW – Lap joint – Carbon Steel – Lack of Fusion Defect

This video captures gas metal arc welding (GMAW) of mild steel in a fillet weld. The weld surface was contaminated with aluminum powder traces that caused the lack of fusion defect in the bottom plate.

5. Spatter

Spatter consists of molten metal droplets expelled from the weld pool due to high current settings or improper gas flow. These droplets solidify on the workpiece surface, requiring additional cleanup. 

Technical implications

Beyond aesthetic concerns, spatter can affect component fit-up in assemblies and requires post-weld cleanup. While spatter does not directly weaken the weld, it can compromise the precision and surface finish required in high-quality manufacturing.

Common causes
  • Excessive Current: High current expels metal particles from the weld pool.
  • Improper Polarity: Incorrect polarity affects arc stability.
  • Insufficient Shielding Gas: Low gas flow results in scattered particles on the surface.
How to prevent
  • Lower welding current to prevent excessive molten metal expulsion.
  • Adjust polarity to ensure a stable arc; direct shielding gas to protect against airborne particles.
  • Use anti-spatter spray as needed, especially on surrounding areas of the workpiece.

Poor Spatter defect images

Spatter

Video: GMAW - Manual - Tee Joint - High Spatter (3 Coupon Welds)

This video captures a manual GMAW process on a Tee joint, highlighting spatter formation across three coupon welds. Despite stable arc behavior, moderate spatter is observed, likely due to shielding gas turbulence or voltage fluctuations. The bead remains consistent, ensuring sufficient fusion. Process optimization may reduce spatter without compromising penetration.

SMAW - Bead on Flat Steel Plate - Trailing - Lots of Spatter - Monochrome

This video showcases a SMAW bead-on-plate weld using a trailing technique. High spatter levels and irregular bead consistency suggest unstable arc conditions, possibly due to excessive amperage or inconsistent electrode angle. Arc intensity is relatively high, which may contribute to excess metal expulsion. Optimizing parameters could enhance bead uniformity.

6. Porosity

Porosity arises when gas becomes entrapped within the molten weld pool and solidifies as voids or bubbles, often due to contaminants, inadequate shielding gas, or residual moisture. During high-temperature welding, these gases escape unevenly, leaving pockets within the weld metal. 

Technical implications

Porosity reduces the weld's density and strength, which is critical in pressurized environments. Applications in piping or pressurized vessels are particularly vulnerable, as porosity can lead to leaks and structural failures under operational stress.

Common causes
  • Contaminated Base Material: Presence of oxides, moisture, or oil that introduces gases into the weld pool.
  • Inadequate Shielding Gas Flow: Insufficient shielding gas flow allows air and moisture to enter.
  • Moisture in Filler Material: Moisture in the filler releases gas during welding, creating bubbles.
How to prevent
  • Clean the base metal thoroughly to eliminate oils, rust, and dirt, which can introduce gas into the weld.
  • Store filler materials in a dry area to avoid moisture absorption; preheat materials if necessary.
  • Ensure proper shielding gas flow (15-20 CFH) and avoid drafts in the work area.

Porosity images

Porosity-white

GMAW - Stainless Steel - Robotic Automotive - Porosity Defects

The robotic GMAW process on stainless steel exhibits significant porosity defects, likely due to shielding gas inconsistencies, oxidation, or entrapped contaminants. The instability in bead formation suggests inadequate process control, emphasizing the need for optimized welding parameters and environmental shielding conditions to mitigate gas entrapment.

GMAW - Short Circuit - Butt Weld - Trailing Side View - Porosity Defect

This video captures a GMAW short-circuit process on a butt weld, filmed from a trailing side view. The welding arc is active, but porosity defects are consistently visible along the bead. These defects were caused by surface contamination in the middle section of the weld.

7. Overlap

Overlap occurs when molten metal flows onto the surface of the parent material without bonding due to an inadequate arc angle or excessive filler deposition rate. This lack of fusion produces a superficial layer of metal, failing to create a cohesive bond. 

Technical implications

Overlaps compromise the weld surface, reducing its corrosion resistance and creating potential points of weakness. This flaw is particularly detrimental in applications that require strict surface integrity, as it undermines the weld’s longevity and resistance to environmental degradation.

Common causes
  • High Welding Speed: Fast welding allows molten metal to flow onto the surface without bonding.
  • Excessive Filler Metal: Too much filler metal is deposited without enough fusion control.
  • Inadequate Heat Distribution: Insufficient heat distribution prevents bonding with the base metal.
How to prevent
  • Lower the welding current to avoid excessive heat at the edges of the weld.
  • Reduce travel speed to allow more bonding time; maintain a 5-15° electrode angle for even heat distribution.
  • Use a weave technique to fill the edges effectively, especially on vertical welds.

Poor Overlap defect images

Overlap

8. Excess Reinforcement

Excess reinforcement occurs when an excessive amount of filler metal builds up along the weld bead, forming a pronounced convex profile. This is often the result of slow travel speeds or high filler deposition. 

Technical implications

Although structurally less critical, excess reinforcement can create stress risers along the weld surface. It may also require grinding or other post-processing to achieve a uniform surface, particularly in applications requiring strict dimensional tolerances.

Common causes
  • Slow Travel Speed: Slow speed allows excess filler metal buildup.
  • High Filler Metal Input: Too much filler material results in a convex bead.
  • Improper Heat Control: Poor heat control leads to a bulky weld profile.
How to prevent
  • Increase travel speed to avoid over-depositing filler metal and forming a convex profile.
  • Control filler input for a balanced deposition; adjust heat input to achieve a flat bead.
  • Plan to apply post-grind finishing only if necessary, as excess reinforcement may require it.

Excess Reinforcement images

Excess-reinforcement

9. Cracks

Cracks are fractures that appear as the weld cools, often due to rapid cooling, high residual stress, or incompatible material properties. Cracks may be longitudinal, transverse, or crater-type, depending on their orientation and cause. 

Technical implications

Cracks represent a serious risk to structural integrity, serving as focal points for failure under cyclic or static loading. In industries such as aerospace, where component reliability is paramount, the presence of cracks necessitates comprehensive inspection and quality control.

Common causes
  • Rapid Cooling: Fast cooling induces internal stresses in the metal.
  • Material Incompatibility: Materials with different thermal expansion rates cause tension.
  • Residual Stresses: Residual stresses from improper welding techniques.
How to prevent
  • Control the cooling rate to reduce residual stresses; preheat the material to slow cooling if needed.
  • Use materials with compatible thermal expansion properties to minimize stress-related cracking.
  • Employ a post-weld heat treatment when working with high-strength or brittle materials.

Cracks defect images

Cracks

10. Burn through

Burn through happens when excessive heat penetrates entirely through the base metal, resulting in holes or thinning of the material. This defect is prevalent in thin sections where heat control is challenging. 

Technical implications

Burn through drastically weakens the structural integrity of the joint, especially in precision applications such as pipeline welding. Such breaches in material continuity require rework to ensure that the joint meets industry standards.

Common causes
  • High Heat Input: Excessive heat that burns through the base metal, especially in thin sections.
  • Slow Travel Speed: Slow speed allows excessive heat, creating holes.
  • Poor Edge Preparation: Inadequate preparation enables excessive heat penetration at the edge.
How to prevent
  • Use lower heat input, especially for thinner materials, to prevent complete melting through the base.
  • Increase travel speed to disperse heat over a larger area, preventing concentration.
  • Ensure uniform edge preparation for even material thickness, which helps avoid burn-through spots.

Learn more about Burn through defect

Using Video and Audio to Help Detect Welding Defects

Burn through images

Burn-throught

Video: GMAW - Carbon Steel Plate - Identified Burn Through Weld Defect

This video demonstrates GMAW on a carbon steel plate. The high heat input led to a burn-through defect, visible as localized penetration irregularities. The weld bead lacks uniformity, indicating insufficient control of process parameters critical for preventing such defects.

Video: GMAW - Carbon Steel Plate - Burn Through

In this video, the excessive heat input during gas metal arc welding (GMAW) of a lap joint lead to a burn through defect and subsequent collapse of the weld pool through the bottom plate.

Welding Defect Detection Using Vision and Audio

Get real-world insights and elevate weld quality — access the webinar on demand.

Watch Webinar
xiris-thermal-camera

Weld Defect Detection with Xiris Automation Technology

Xiris’s welding cameras deliver real-time, high-resolution imaging that overcomes the limits of traditional inspection methods. Designed for continuous monitoring, they enable immediate defect detection and adjustments during welding, ensuring higher quality and improved productivity. Here's how:

  • Real-Time, High-Definition Imaging: Unlike post-process inspections, Xiris cameras let operators monitor the weld pool, arc, and surrounding area live, catching issues like porosity or cracks instantly and adjusting on the spot.
  • Detection of Subtle Inconsistencies: Advanced optics detect minor weld variations, such as penetration or alignment issues, crucial for precision applications to ensure high-quality results.
  • Automated Data Collection for Improvement: Xiris systems record footage and data, enabling manufacturers to analyze trends, refine processes, and maintain compliance with traceable quality records.
  • Non-Destructive, Continuous Monitoring: Xiris technology avoids production interruptions, offering real-time monitoring to reduce downtime and ensure consistent weld quality.
  • Integrating Xiris cameras streamlines quality management, minimizes defects, and boosts productivity on the production floor.